An-Nur 43: Don’t you see that Allah makes the clouds move, then gathers and stacks them up? Then you see that rain comes out of them. From the sky, from the (clouds that are like) mountains there, Allah sends down hail. Allah makes them fall on whoever desires (from Allah). And Allah keeps them away from whoever desires that (from Allah). The spark of the lightning (in these clouds) nearly blinds the eyes.

A. Metin Saruhan · 22 February 2022 · Misinterpreted Verses

The misinterpretation

Do you not see that Allah drives some clouds; Then he puts them together and stacks them on top of each other. Here you see that rain comes out among them. He brings down hail from the sky, from the mountains (clouds the size of mountains) therein. Now he hits whomever he wishes. He drives him away from whomever He wills. The flash of the (of these clouds) lightning almost blinds the eyes.

The right translation

Don’t you see that Allah makes the clouds move, then gathers and stacks them up? Then you see that rain comes out of them. From the sky, from the (clouds that are like) mountains there, Allah sends down hail. Allah makes them fall on whoever desires (from Allah). And Allah keeps them away from whoever desires that (from Allah). The spark of the lightning (in these clouds) nearly blinds the eyes.

Explanation

This is where this verse goes wrong: He causes it to strike whom He wills. And takes it away from whom He wills. The truth is: He causes it to strike whomsoever He wills. And He removes it from those who wish.

In this Verse, as they have always made the same mistake, they have again opened the Verse by blaming our Lord. Verily: So He causes it to fall upon whom He wills (among you). In this Verse, we have written that our Lord has no will over people, that every soul has made a covenant with our Lord, and that the desires and wishes of people are written for them as destiny, and that this will never change, and that in this case, our Lord has no will over people. It is explained in detail in Verse 172 of Surah A'râf. Why were we created, where were we created, why did He make a covenant with mankind and why did He send us into the world even though He knew what we were? You can get information there.

What is said in the video

Yes.

In verse 43 of Surah An-Nur there is also a mistake. Do you not see that Allah drives some clouds? Yes. Then He brings them together and piles them up. Then you see rain coming out from between them. From the sky, from the mountains there, from mountain-sized clouds He sends down hail. Then He makes it strike whom He wills. And He turns it away from whom He wills. The flash of these clouds' lightning nearly takes away the sight, it says.

Now, we all know how rain falls. Allah Almighty: these vapours, when they rise up as clouds, reach a certain level. There, when they meet a cold layer, they condense. From the warm combining with the cold, raindrops form. That is how rain falls. If it reaches a colder layer, it falls as hail. If it reaches a normal layer, in its cold layer it falls as snow. The wrong part here: then He makes it strike whoever among you wills it. Because if he has rebelled against Allah and his life span is also complete, there it strikes him. And He turns it away from the one who wills. That is, from those who pray, whose life, sir, is longer, He turns it away.

The flash of the clouds' lightning nearly takes away their sight, it says. Yes.

Here the ones who will are always people. Does Allah not will? He does. He willed and created us. He willed and created these worlds. If Allah wills a thing, He creates it. But Allah Almighty, who made a covenant with us, listen to this carefully, and fix your minds on this. This is important. When Allah Almighty made a covenant with us, outside our covenant He has no further ruling over us. Because He made the covenant with us, placed our covenant in us as characters, and wrote our wishes and desires, our intent, for us as destiny; our matter is done. No more, in the world, 'O Allah, make me like this, O Allah, make this like that, O Allah, make that like this, O Allah, give me this.' His work concerning us is done.

He programmed it according to our wishes and desires. Whatever is needed in the world so that I can prove what kind of person I am: what feelings He gave me, what provision He gave me, with what want, with what wealth He tested me, with what afflictions, so that I am held as a witness over myself, so that I do not say to Allah Almighty 'had You done this like that, I would have done so', He holds us as witnesses over ourselves, and when our life is complete, we go on the journey to the hereafter. Every soul shall taste death. Your return is to Me. Why did He send us? So that we prove what kind of person we are.

Yes. In that case: Allah will put whom He wills into paradise, whom He wills into hell, make it strike whom He wills, not strike whom He wills, save whom He wills, hopefully He will do so. May Allah reform them. No one can attribute such qualities to Allah. Yes.